Had a poor experience with Gameloot very recently.
Mint condition disc, which I checked before sending, was marked as scratched. Did get the game but they've changed my disc with their own scratched one and returned. Even the game case has a tear. Seems they are keeping the good discs.
I'm done with Gameloot. Will either sell on the forum or else to a local shop. Atleast I can make sure I get my own disc in return.