Not really surprising - Blizzard's reputation has been going down and Diablo's specifically is coming on the back of Diablo 3 and 4 which were good but not in the "legendary" tier I would say (Diablo 3 was a mess at launch too)! Also the Diablo trailer shown was an expansion pack to Diablo 4 and not a brand new game
Meanwhile Divinity is coming on the back of The Massive Baldur's Gate 3, is Larian's own IP so they can go much more crazy than they ever could with BG3 and the trailer itself is quite disturbing and intriguing as to where Larian will go (Not to mention - Divinity Original Sin 2 was also a 90+ meta game before BG3 released)
I know some people likes first person in games especially in horror games but somehow I feel a bit detached to first person perspective games.
Silent Hill series and recently released Silent Hill f was great. 3rd person and spooky af. Loved it.